Last chance for negotiations

Nowood Watershed Improvement District moves forward with condemnation of private land for Alkali Creek Reservoir 

Nowood Watershed Improvement District filed complaints for condemnation against five Hyattville area property owners in Big Horn County District Court November 10. 

The move comes as NWID faces a reversion deadline of July 1, 2027, to finalize easement negotiations for Alkali Creek Reservoir and begin the project or risk losing state funding. At a joint meeting November 5, legislators tabled a request from Wyoming Water Development Office, which would have bumped the ACR project’s total allocation from $59 million to $103.4 million and set a completion date in 2032. 

“If you want to know why it can’t get resolved, it is because we just haven’t had this normal ability to have a good faith process of negotiation,” Rep. Martha Lawley (Worland), chair of the 2026 Select Water Committee, said of the eminent domain proceedings. ACR was first proposed in 2008, with NWID formed as its sponsor in 2015. The estimated price of the project has skyrocketed as it has been repeatedly delayed, originally priced at $35 million in 2017. 

“I actually think it’s the continued extension, I would argue, that has created an environment that doesn’t provide finality ... To extend it further only complicates the problem further and increases potential costs,” Lawley said. 

The requested $44 million budget increase would have partially gone towards acquiring easements and putting Anita Ditch in pipe, an attempt to garner the remaining five landowners’ easements. That would all be voided or altered if eminent domain is finalized. A geotechnical investigation by project engineer TriHydro found conditions that would require the dam be wider than originally planned. The dam site, then, would not have the necessary material in its borrow area and material would need to be brought in, also increasing costs. Inflation out to 2032 was included in the proposed budget increase, as well. 

Though legislation for the project dictates that state funds can not be used for eminent domain proceedings after January 1, 2027, the state clarified November 5 that NWID would be solely responsible for funding regardless, as it is the Water Development Commission’s policy not to participate in legal fees, including eminent domain. 

Local stakeholders in the project from both sides of the lawsuit were present at the joint meeting. 

“This does not reflect what one would consider a $100 million project for the betterment of the people of Wyoming,” Michelle Hamilton of Hamilton Ranch, Inc., one of the defendants, said. “During this journey and due in part to the poor conduct of board members, we have been forced to hire legal consult simply to protect ourselves from retaliation. The project has cost us financially, professionally and personally.”

Hamilton called eminent domain the “easy way out,” “not the Wyoming way.” 

John Joyce and Mitch Vigil were reelected to the NWID board recently, with Todd Jones taking former board chair Martin Mercer’s place. Joyce recounted the district’s difficulties in acquiring easements and touted the project’s potential benefits to the area; water storage and recreation opportunities. 

Mercer, who is currently president of the Anita Ditch, reported, “If we could get in a room and visit about this, I think we’re close ... just wanted to clarify that.”

Lawmakers noted that there is still time, even with eminent domain proceedings filed, for good faith negotiations. Hamiltons told legislators there were potential opportunities for an agreement. In a special meeting of NWID attended by Karla Pomeroy of Northern Wyoming News November 11, defendants Tommy Searfoss and Tom Shirran expressed willingness to negotiate on their easements. Paul Hughes also told the board he would reach out. Diamond S Ranch’s status on negotiations has not been made public. An eminent domain hearing is set for December 7 in Big Horn County District Court.

“I’m not going to weigh in on the district trying to obtain easements besides recognizing that we’ve all had discussions about state funding and the constitutionality of using that state funding,” WWDO’s Jason Mead said. “And then also recognizing that the legislature’s desire last year was, I think, to see easements in place before they came back asking for anything else and at this point in time, those easements are not in place. At the same time, being the Water Development Office and myself, recognizing the importance of storage in this state, any time we have a permit from the federal agencies to build storage, I’m in favor of that.”

Mead explained that if no progress is made by July 1, the $59 million allocated for ACR would return to Account III, which specifically funds reservoir projects. 

“Once the easements potentially are in place, the district could come back and ask for all the money they need to construct the project at that time and then be more in line with what the legislature’s desires are; to have easements in place before they ask for anything else,” Mead said. 

Lawley pointed out that if NWID loses any of the five condemnation cases, that could be a complete gamechanger for the project. The legislators planned to revisit discussions during their December 17-18 meeting.  

Category: